| Benjamin Dunbar |
Gershom Hall Mass |
| Hannah Hathaway |
Lucy Snow Mass. |
| Benjamin E. Dunbar | Rhoda Hall |
| bd. 1 Dec 1776 Halifax, Plymouth County,
Massachusetts occ. dd. Between 1830 - 1850 brd. |
bd. 12 Mar 1784 Harwich, Barnstable Co., Massachusetts occ. Alias. Rhida dd. Btw 1850 - 60 after husband's death brd. |
| 1810 Census Wellfleet, Barnstable Co., MA 1820 Census Chatham, Barnstable Co., MA 1830 Census Chatham, Barnstable Co., MA 1840 Census NY, St. Lawrence Co. (Benjamin Dunbar w/5 male 2 female children) Is this our Benjamin? |
1850 Census Michigan, St. Joseph County, Mendon (living w/ Olive) |
| Safronay Dunbar Rhoday Dunbar Daniel H. Dunbar Rhoda Dunbar Benjamin S. Dunbar Moses Dunbar Rebecca Dunbar Susanna Dunbar (13 Mar 1817 Chatham, Barnstable Co., Mass.) Hannah Dunbar (28 Aug 1821 Chatham, Barnstable Co., Mass.) Olive Hall Dunbar (10 Jun 1823 Chatham, Barnstable Co., Mass.) Lucy Snow Dunbar (25 Sept 1827 Chatham, Barnstable Co., Mass.) |
Notes: Marshal Dunbar (b. abt 1837 Ohio) shown living in Riddle household with Rhoda Dunbar. Is this teenager the last child from Rhoda? If so, most likely John Davis Riddle and Olive Dunbar would have been married in Ohio, especially since their 1st child was born 1846 in Ohio too.